The following APCU-member institutions are currently members of Educational and Institutional Insurance Administrators, Inc.
- Alma College
- Arcadia University
- Austin College
- Blackburn College
- Centre College
- Davidson College
- Davis & Elkins College
- Eckerd College
- Hastings College
- Johnson C. Smith University
- King College
- Illinois College
- Lake Forest College
- Lyon College
- Millikin University
- Montreat College
- Queens University of Charlotte
- Schreiner University
- Stillman College
- Trinity University
- Warren Wilson College
- Whitworth College
- William Peace University
- Wilson College
The following non-member institutions are also members of EIIA:
- Auburn Theological Seminary
- Austin Presbyterian Theological Seminary
- Princeton Theological Seminary
